The Well Plated Cookbook is here! Slow Cooker Broccoli Cheese Soup
Slow Cooker Broccoli Cheese Soup – Calling all Panera broccoli cheese soup lovers! I’m popping in with a healthy recipe for an easy Slow Cooker Broccoli Cheese Soup that takes less than 10 minutes to prep. This is one of the best crock pot recipes to make you feel just as warm and toasty as the Panera original.
I originally posted this recipe on the last day of a trip I took to Charleston, South Carolina with this guy. (If you’re heading to Charleston soon, be sure to check out my Charleston restaurant and activity guide.)
I decided to share the recipe again today, because it’s become a true reader favorite, and because I’m once again in the midst of a crazy travel spree, which is exactly how this easy slow cooker broccoli cheese soup recipe was inspired.
When I think back on our trip to Charleston, the first thing that comes to mind is ALL THE FOOD.
We chose the city based on its reputation as a foodie paradise, and it did not disappoint. If you followed along on Instagram, you witnessed a portion of the mass seafood/soul food havoc the two of us wreaked.
I say “portion” because, by the end of the trip, the culinary consumption reached a level I was embarrassed to continue posting.
For me, eating and drinking is, quite literally, my favorite way to gain a taste for a city. While I loved every bite and sip of our trip, whenever I return from vacation, it’s with an acute craving for wholesome foods and green veggies.
I also return to an inbox stuffed with unread emails and a dresser devoid of clean underwear. Reality, we have arrived.
Slow Cooker Broccoli Cheese Soup—The Perfect Healthy Meal
This easy slow cooker broccoli cheese soup recipe is perfect when you are in need of a healthy meal but have zero time to cook it, a position I’m in now. I’ve been out of town the past two weekends and leave again this Thursday. I adore traveling, but whenever I am out of town back-to-back weeks, the “no time to cook” song becomes a refrain. I suspect that, on many a busy weeknight, it’s one you sing too.
Nearly every broccoli and cheese soup recipe I’ve found calls for the initial step of making a base cheese sauce on the stove, including recipes designed for the crock pot.
Because I know we don’t always have time to fuss with this kind of prep, I decided to see if I could create a slow cooker broccoli and cheese soup entirely via the “dump and go” method: dump the ingredients into your crock pot; walk away; return hours later to a dinner that’s ready to serve.
I almost made it.
Although you can skip the cheese sauce, and I’d still bet my last spoonful that this is the easiest broccoli and cheese soup recipe you’ll find, you do need to blend the soup with an immersion blender or food processor prior to serving.
It’s a small extra step that’s well worth the effort for the texture and body it provides.
The flavor of this soup is a dead-ringer for Panera’s broccoli cheese soup, and although its texture is a bit thinner than I’d originally envisioned (a result of skipping that fussy cheese sauce base), I still found it to be plenty cheesy and satisfying.
If you love broccoli cheese soups like this, make sure to try this Broccoli Cauliflower Soup too!
More Comforting Slow Cooker Soup Recipes
- Crockpot Lentil Soup
- Crockpot Vegetable Beef Soup
- Crockpot Beef Stew
- Crockpot Butternut Squash Soup
- And all these crockpot soups!
Recommended Tools to Make Slow Cooker Broccoli Cheese Soup
- 6-quart programmable slow cooker
- Immersion blender: it makes pureeing soups like this one easier (and safer) than transferring the piping hot soup mixture to a blender or food processor in batches.
- If you prefer a food processor, or are in the market for a new one, I have used and loved this one for almost nine years.
Slow Cooker Broccoli and Cheese Soup
Ingredients
- 5 cups chopped broccoli florets - about 16 ounces
- 1 cup grated carrots, - you can grate yourself or use bagged, pre-cut julienne carrots
- 1 medium yellow onion - finely diced
- 3 cloves garlic - minced
- 2 ounces reduced fat cream cheese - do not use fat free
- 1 teaspoon dried oregano
- 1/4 teaspoon freshly grated nutmeg
- 2 1/2 cups reduced sodium chicken broth - or vegetable broth
- 1 can 2% evaporated milk - (12 ounces)
- 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
- 1/4 teaspoon black pepper
- 8 ounces sharp cheddar cheese, grated* - (1 block)
Instructions
- Place the broccoli, carrots, onion, and garlic in the bottom of 5-to-6-quart slow cooker. Top with the cream cheese, oregano, nutmeg, and chicken broth. Stir to evenly distribute the ingredients. Cover and cook on high for 2 hours or low for 4-6 hours, until the broccoli is tender.
- Remove the lid and stir in the evaporated milk. With an immersion blender, puree about 3/4 of the soup, so that it is mostly smooth but still has a few chunks of broccoli remaining. Alternatively, you can puree the soup in 1 cup-sized batches in a food processor or blender. (Be careful—it's hot and prone to splatter!)
- Recover the soup and let cook on low for 10 minutes until warmed through. Stir the salt, pepper, and grated cheese. Taste and add additional salt and pepper as desired. Recover and cook on high until the cheese is fully melted and the soup is hot, about 5 additional minutes. Serve warm.
Notes
I am sharing this post in partnership with Pick ‘n Save. As always, all opinions are my own. Thanks for supporting the brands and companies that make it possible for me to continue providing high quality content to you!
This post contains some affiliate links, which means that I make a small commission off items you purchase at no additional cost to you.
Charleston is such a magical place and the food scene there is world class. It sounds like you had the opportunity to indulge in a lot of what the city has to offer in the culinary space. But alas we all must return to reality and. . . this soup. What a great way to transition back into the daily grind. I’ve been giving my slow cooker quite the workout as of late. . .and interestingly enough I was wanting to make a healthy broccoli soup. The timing for this post couldn’t be perfect.
Lynn, I am IN LOVE with Charleston. It’s hard to leave :) Thanks for your note!
oh yummy! This looks so good!
oh gurl. i too had broccoli soup on the blog mind today too!! yours looks sooo delish. and i am very jealous of your charleston trip! can’t wait for the full recap. I was there years ago for a bach and it was the best. xo
This soup looks so creamy and comforting! It’s definitely soup season around here because everyone is getting sick on campus- I would so love a bowl of this right about now :)
One of my fave things!
I’m still on the fence about buying a slow cooker, though if it means I can make delicious soups like this then it’s definitely a huge plus in favour of getting one! Looks delicious =)
I vote yes Teffy! I don’t use my slow cooker for every meal, but it really comes in handy and is especially great for soups.
Get the Ninja cooking system it’s almost all I ever use anymore. You get much faster cooking and everything is juicy and tender
Thanks for the suggestion, Colleen!
Your v welcome you’ll love it!
This is the one I have.
Ninja 6 Quart 3 In 1 Multi-System Slow Cooker (Certified Refurbished) (Red) https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0743HK9NX/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_1esnCbTW7VWTM
A girl after my own heart! Broccoli cheese soup is always my go-to, and I’m so glad to have a recipe I can make ahead! Can’t wait to make this!
Thank you so much Mary Caroline! I hope you love the soup.
Erin,
It was a pleasure flying with you and your husband. Sorry if I snored…long week! I hope you guys enjoyed your stay in Charleston and were entertained by our airport. Your blog is fun, and I’ll be sure to keep reading!
JJ, you didn’t snore at all, and I have to thank you for your stellar food recs! We hit up Amen Street, the bar at The Mac, and Craftsman and loved them all. I need to get back to Charleston soon. It’s such a great town, and there’s still so much left to try. Have a great day, and I hope our paths cross again!
Broccoli cheese soup is a favorite around here! Love that you made it healthier!
We made this last night for dinner and I ate a bowl for breakfast. If that doesn’t tell you how good this is I just don’t know what does! :)
This is a keeper!
Annie, that is the highest praise I could for! Thanks so much for trying the recipe and letting me know how it came out!
Thanks for the review. It’s nice to read a comment from someone who has actually tried it and not just saying they’re going to make it or it looks delish ;)
Looks delicious.!! Thanks for a great recipe..??????
My family really enjoyed this soup. It was a terrific way to get my kids to eat some vegetables! Thank you!
Jocelyn, I am so so happy to hear this!! Thanks for letting me know how it turned out for you and your family!
if i cook this tonight before bed, will i be able to warm it up for lunch tomorrow? (not sure with the melted cheese in it)
Definitely Lisa! I’d just warm it on about 75% power and stop to stir it periodically. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
Can you substitute whipping cream for the canned milk? I’m not so worried about the fat just trying to avoid as much processed products as possible
Definitely Lee! Half and half might work as well—it just depends on how rich you’d like the soup to be. I hope you enjoy it!
Looks and sounds great! Question: What could I substitute for the cream cheese? Or could I just omit it? Cream cheese and I don’t get along. :)
Hi Suzy! Honestly, I think it would be hard to find a substitute for the cream cheese. The soup will be a bit thinner if you omit it, but if this doesn’t bother you, you can just leave it out.
You could always coat the veggies in flour before you add the broth. It will give it a thicker texture. Or if you have the time you could make a roux.
Thanks for the suggestion Samantha! I’ve never tried the recipe this way, but it would be a good experiment. If you decide to try the soup this way, I’d love to hear how it comes out.
Do you think frozen veggies would be ok for this?
Holly, I’ve never tried this recipe with frozen veggies, so it would be an experiment, but I don’t see why it wouldn’t work. The soup might be a bit more liquidy though, since the veggies will thaw in the slow cooker. I’d suggest reducing the amount of liquid in the soup, then checking the cooking time early. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
Have you tried freezing this recipe and if so how did it turn out?
Jorene, it’s been a while since I made this, but I’m fairly certain that I froze it and that it turned out just fine! The only soup recipes I really have trouble freezing are those that call for coconut milk because it tends to solidify and not thaw properly.
Hi, do I have to use evaporated milk, or could I use slightly less than 2 cups of regular milk?
Hi Susan! I apologize—I thought I responded to this. I recommend the evaporated because it is thicker and will yield a creamier soup. If you don’t mind a thinner consistency, regular milk will be fine. I hope you enjoy it!
Woow!!! Just made your brocoli soup and it was absolutley delicious. my daughter is very hard to make her eat and she asked for more!!! Best soup ever!! You gained a follower!
Adriana, HOORAY! I am so happy to hear this. Thank you. So happy to have you here :)
Tried this recipe tonight and it was fantastic! Didn’t have nutmeg on hand but I still thought it was really rich and flavorful. Great recipe, thanks for sharing!
Jenni, I am so excited to hear this!! Thanks for trying the recipe and letting me know how it came out for you.
When do I add the evaporated milk? Making this recipe today and can’t seem to find it in the directions.
Nevermind, I just found it!!
I noticed someone asked if they could replace the whipping cream with something else. But there is no whipping cream in the ingredients only evaporated milk so I was a little confused about that.
Never mind my last comment. I just realized I read it wrong
Hi! Question: I’m making this as the recipe states, but am curious why we need to dice onion and shred carrots if I’m going to use an immersion blender. Is it to release flavors differently? Or, could I put in larger chunks of veggies assuming they’ll soften while cooking?
Thanks!
Hi Haylea! I found that cutting the veggies that size is what gave me the cook time specified the recipe in the end. You can leave them larger, but the soup will take longer to cook. It’s up to you!
Erin –
Is it possible to puree or finely chop all the veggies up front in the food processor so I don’t have to use an immersion blender afterwards?
Hi Sheri! I actually would not recommend this. The blending is to thicken the soup, not just to chop the veggies smaller. Without blending, the soup will be more brothy, vs. creamy. I hope that helps to answer your question!
Also, what if I have frozen broccoli!?
Sorry for all the typos. I am rushing to get things done during nap time.
Hi Katie! Frozen broccoli should work, though its texture will be a bit “mushier” than if you use fresh. Also, the ad shouldn’t be blocking the recipe—it’s in the box but won’t cover text. Try refreshing the page and/or clearing out your browser’s cache.
Can I used pre-ground nutmeg as a substitute for freshly grated and if so, does the measurement change?
Definitely Emily! No change to the amount.
I’m curious if you can freeze everything prior to cooking. I’m meal prepping and don’t need to cook it today. Would the brocolli get saggy?
Hi Renée! Please see the prior comments about using frozen broccoli. I think the same would apply if you prep things in advance, then froze them. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
This was just okay to me. Wished I had used chicken stock instead of vegetable because it throws the flavor off. I added some parmesan cheese to amp up the flavor because it was so bland tasting. The real flavor of broccoli just doesn’t shine through this recipe as I am used to in my older recipe and I don’t understand why.
Hi Carol! I’m sorry you didn’t love this recipe as much as you hoped. As you can see from the prior comments, it’s been quite popular with other readers, but everyone has different tastes, and I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not have it be as expected. My guess is the flavors were more muted due to the inherent flavor loss that happens with any that vegetables are made in a slow cooker vs. on the stove top. Also, because they are not sauteed first, some flavor loss happens that way (it’s a sacrifice I made in the recipe for the sake of easy prep). The parmesan sounds like a great addition. Also, be sure to use reduced sodium (vs. salt free) broth, as that will impact the flavor too. You may have done that already, but I wanted to call it to your attention just in case.
hey girl this looks so yummy!
Just made your recipe. Loved it. The nutmeg was a nice surprise
I’m so glad you enjoyed it Patricia! Thank you!
I was wondering if anyone knows how this keeps in the refrigerator and/or freezer? I am making the whole thing for just 2 of us and was wondering how to best keep it. Thank you!
Hi Jenn! You can keep this in the refrigerator for 4-5 days or freeze for 2 months. I hope you enjoy it!
OMG ! This Soup is Fabulous !
The receipt came through on my Pinterest Site.
I saw this last night and NEW i had to make it.
I added more broccoli and carrots………I only added more Chicken Stock………..
Otherwise I followed the directions. (I Used the Blender at the end to Blend veggies……but still kept it chunky ).
I cut scallions for garnish and toasted a crusty rustic bread with butter ! RAVES !
Easy…….and GUILT FREE, sorta !
Gail, YAY!!! I am so excited to hear this. Thank you!!
How long do you cook this in crock pot for? And do you set on high or low?
Love Love Love this recipe! The blending is such a fabulous idea. Healthier and makes the texture just perfect!
YAY!!! I cannot say enough how happy this makes me. Thanks for trying the recipe and leaving this kind review!
Hi Kathy! Bubbles can occur depending on how the blender is used (for example, if it’s close to the surface, it will suck in some air, if that makes sense). They should settle down fairly quickly though.
I made the slow cooker broccoli and cheese soup this weekend and it turned out great. I really appreciate that you provide the nutritional information. Thank you.
Liz, I am so so excited to hear that! Thank you!
Hi Sheila! Sorry for the miss—it’s updated now. Thanks for letting me know! Both should be broth, though you can use either for the recipe. I hope you enjoy it very much!
Thanks! I’m sure that we will enjoy it! Sorry, I just noticed my own typos!
I’m making this RIGHT NOW, but I accidentally loaded everything into the slow cooker at the same time. Fingers crossed it turns out okay.
I hope it turned out Cathy! Thanks for trying the recipe.
I just did the same thing 😧😧😧
Hi Cassie, I hope it still turned out delicious!
I was wondering why you need to use reduce fat and not fat free?
Hi Keeley, fat-free dairy products can be more prone to curdling when heated, so I don’t use it here.
When do you add broccoli to chicken noodle soup in a slow cooker, so the broccoli is not over cooked
Hi Justin, I can’t say for sure with a chicken noodle soup recipe. My best guess is that you’d probably want to add it toward the end of the overall cooking time so the broccoli doesn’t turn mushy.
This soup was so good!! I love that it has tons of veggies in it. I was so surprised by the flavor, it is spot on to the Panera brocolli cheddar soup!
Thanks, Sammie! I’m so glad you enjoyed the recipe, and I appreciate your taking the time to leave this nice comment!
Did you ever make this with chicken? Do you think I could throw chicken in the crock pot too?
Hi Lisa, I haven’t added chicken to the recipe before, so I can’t say for sure! I think if you wanted to try it, you’d want to add bite-size pieces of already-cooked chicken to the crockpot *after* blending the soup in step 2, then warm it up for 10 minutes as instructed before adding the salt, pepper, and cheese. If you try it out, I’d love to hear how it goes!
Going to make this for a family Christmas party so I was going to double it. How long would you suggest cooking it for double the batch? Thank you!
Hi Brooke, I’m not quite sure since I’ve never doubled the recipe before! I would suggest checking it according to the specified times in the recipe, then check it every 15 to 30 minutes from there depending on how much longer it seems the vegetables need. I hope you enjoy it!
May I ask what brand and/or version (medium, sharp, extra sharp, SUPER sharp, etc.) of cheddar cheese you use? I’m still struggling with find a good one that melts well for many recipes.
Hi Traci, I love sharp cheddar grated right off the block (full fat when melting is really critical). I buy all sorts of different brands. The main thing to remember is not to buy pre-shredded. It has a starch on it to keep it from caking that causes the cheese to melt less smoothly.
Our entire family loves this soup, even my picky toddler! THANK YOU!
I’m so happy to hear that Jane, thank you so much for letting me know! Toddler approval is the best of all :-)
I’m a big fan of using the slow cooker, but not when you have to do a lot of work in addition to that. So I was really excited to try this recipe. We made it a few months ago and LOVED it!!! My husband didn’t leave a drop in his bowl. (Panera’s broccoli and cheddar was his favorite until we tried this.) I made it exactly as written, except I used cheese that was already shredded. So easy to make, tasty, and easy to adapt! Looking forward to having this again tonight :) Thank you for sharing.
I’m thrilled to hear this recipe was a winner for you, Amy! Thank you so much for giving it a try and taking the time to leave this wonderful review!
Prepared this for our dinner tonight. It was delicious. Wouldn’t change a thing!
I’m so glad you enjoyed the soup, Karen! And I appreciate your taking the time to leave this lovely review. Thank you!
Looks delicious
Thank you!
This was absolutely delicious!! Very easy to make (which says A LOT coming from me)!! I used vegetable broth and it was perfect! I do wish it was a little thicker because I love how creamy the Panera soup is, but you still can’t beat that taste!! Thanks for the recipe!!
Kaitlyn, I’m so happy to hear you enjoyed the soup! Thank YOU for taking the time to share your feedback and leave this wonderful review!
I loved this! Very easy to make. Thanks, Erin :)
Vickie, I’m so glad you enjoyed this recipe! Thanks so much for taking the time to leave this awesome review!
Hi Tracy, I’m sorry to hear the soup didn’t turn out as expected. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not have it come out (especially after seeing comments from people who enjoyed it!), so I truly wish you would have loved this.
I made this over the weekend and although it was a big hit my family would have liked it to be thicker. I used full fat cream cheese instead of reduced fat. Is there anything else I can add to make it thicker?
Hi Sharon, I’m glad to hear you enjoyed it! You can use less chicken stock, or you could also try making a cornstarch slurry and stirring that in toward the end.
Hi! I accidnetly added the evaporated milk at the beginning of cook time. Do you think it will still be good for dinner tonight or should I plan on making something else?
Hi Whitney, I know I’m probably seeing this too late, but it’s possible that the milk would curdle if it was put in too early. I hope it came out for you and would love to hear how it went!
It didn’t curdle. I added 1/2 and 1/2 in the last 30 minutes in hope that it would thicken. I also didn’t have quite enough chicken broth and used a splash of beef broth…surprisingly turned out really good! My 1 year old daughter and 2 year old niece loved it! My niece even requested it for breakfast haha!
Whitney, I’m so glad to hear it turned out! Thanks so much for reporting back. :)
Hello! Great recipe! I definitely didn’t as much time to soften the veggies in the beginning – making it a great weeknight dinner.
I’m so glad you enjoyed the soup, Emmalilly! Thanks for taking the time to leave this feedback!
I’m excited to try this for dinner! I have a question- the veggies and cream cheese and broth are in the crock pot right now, but the broth mixture doesn’t completely cover the veggies. Should it? Do I need to add more broth?
Thank you!!!
Hi Hannah, I realize you’ll have finished the soup by now, but the broth mixture doesn’t need to cover the veggies—I’d stick with the amount of liquid called for in the recipe. I hope it turned out and that you enjoyed it!
Hello,
Will it still taste OK if I don’t blend it?
Hi Rachael, blending is important for thickening the soup. Without blending, the soup will be more brothy versus creamy and will be a different texture. The taste will probably still be similar since all the same ingredients are used, but as noted in the blog post, I definitely prefer the blended version. I hope that helps!
Hi! Thanks for posting. I also LOVE Charleston!! I wish I were closer so I could visit often! I am new to cooking. I do own a large crockpot but found that I have been wasteful. I am trying to portion out recipes so that I can make them in a 1.5 quart crockette instead. Can you give advice on how much I should use above for a 1.5 quart crockette? Half would still be too much, I was thinking maybe 1/4 of what you have above?
Thank you so much. If not, I will try in the larger crockpot and freeze remainder.
-Laura
Hi Laura, the recipe as written doesn’t fill a 6-quart slow cooker, so half may fit in your small one. (The recipe serves 6, so if you were to scaling to less than half, you’d only end up with maybe two small servings). Note that since the crock will be fuller, it may take longer to cook as well. The recipe does freeze well for up to 2 months if you decide to go with the larger batch! Good luck!
Made this recipe this week and my family went nuts for it, including my two year old and four year old! The only change I had to make was substituting half and half for the evaporated milk (I forgot to buy it). It was SO easy, tasty, and satisfying which is essential having a newborn and two other young ones in the house. This will definitely be added to our regular rotation this winter!
Katherine, I’m thrilled to hear the recipe was a hit for your family! Thanks so much for giving the soup a try and for taking the time to leave this awesome review!
Accidentally added in the evaporated milk with all the ingredients and then cooked on low. We are still enjoying – Next time I will make it right!
I’m glad you still enjoyed the recipe, Lauren! Thanks so much for leaving this great review!
Hoping to make this tomorrow but I am currently making chicken stock in my crock pot. Can I make this on the stove top instead? Have you tried with this recipe? Thanks in advance!
Hi Erin, I think making this on the stovetop should work just fine! (And, of course, it would take less time to cook than in the slow cooker.) I hope you enjoy!
This was every bit as delicious as claimed! I didn’t think it was too thin but puréed most of the broccoli in. Thanks for the new family favorite!
I’m so glad you enjoyed the soup, Heather! Thank YOU for taking the time to leave this nice review!
Can I use unsweetened almond milk or greek yogurt instead of evaporated milk?
Hi Lisa! I think almond milk would be too thin. I’d suggest sticking with the evaporated milk, then if you want to stir in Greek yogurt at the end (let the soup cool first) to thicken it up even more, you can try that.
I’m wondering what you think about adding a can of rinsed and drained white beans to add protein and help thicken? I’m ok if it changes the flavor a bit—would you alter anything else if I add this?
Sarah, I think you can stir them right in at the end! If you puree them in, that will definitely change the flavor and consistency, but it’s totally up to you. You could always experiment with adding them just to part of the soup, tasting it, then seeing how you like it. I’d also suggest adjusting the seasoning after you add the beans in case it needs more salt and pepper. If you decide to try it, I’d love to hear how it goes!
Thanks, This looks so good!
I hope you love it Marci!
This was easy & amazing! Thank you for sharing!!! I will add this to my favorite soups.
Kathy, I’m glad to hear it’s a new favorite! Thanks for taking the time to leave this wonderful review.
Made this soup tonight, it was excellent thanks for the recipe. Added one cup of quinoa for a healthy kick and to thicken the texture and compensate for the extra liquid created from the frozen broccoli used. Swapped Parmesan for grated cheese. Thanks again.
Roddy, thanks so much for taking the time to leave this review and share your tweaks! I’m glad to hear you enjoyed the recipe.
Your recipe looks amazing, I forgot my phone when I went to the store so I couldn’t get the ingredients, but I will. I have pinned on 2 boards. Would be so good on a chilly night.
Thank you for sharing!
I followed the recipe, but my soup had a gritty texture, which I’m assuming is due to the broccoli bits? I used an immersion blender. The Panera broccoli cheddar soup has a smooth and creamy texture, no grit. This recipe tasted pretty good, but was not like the Panera version.
Michelle, that is the first time I’ve heard about the grit! It might be how they were pureed or that the soup didn’t cook long enough. You could try stirring in extra cheese or Greek yogurt to make it creamier, in case that helps. Regardless, I’m sorry that this didn’t meet your expectations. I know that is disappointing.
USE CORN STARCH at the end to thicken it. You mix it with a little water and stir it up good then stir it into the hot and on high slow cooker. It will start to thicken quickly so be patient instead of adding too much and making it too thick.
I use this method when doing a pot roast to make gravy. It works beautifully every time and unlike flour doesn’t need to be cooked down for a long period to avoid a funny taste.
Thanks for sharing your method, Cori! I hope you enjoyed the chili.
Can you use almond flour instead of all-purpose to reduce carbs? I read in comments above about using heavy whipping cream in place of evaporated milk which is what I would do. thanks!
Linda, this soup doesn’t actually call for all purpose flour at all, so no need to add almond flour either. I hope you enjoy it!
Just made this and it was really good. However it was quite watery and I followed directions exactly. Thinking next time I may use less broth or more veggies to make it thicker or try the corn starch. Thank you for recipe!
Hi Shelley, I’m glad you enjoyed it! Those are the tips I recommend for making the soup thicker, so I hope you love it next time you try it too!
Made this today, it is Very Good, will make again!!!!
Whoooot! So happy to hear it Gail. Thanks for letting me know!
This soup is amazing and better than any I’ve had at a restaurant! It was also delicious leftover for lunch the next day!
Hooray! So glad to hear it. Thank you for sharing!
so delicious. Just loved it.
YAY, I am so glad, thank you!
Made this last night. I had everything on hand to make it except evaporated milk, so I used 1 cup milk and 1/2 cup cream. I also whisked in 2 tbsp of flour to my milk mixture before stirring it into the soup, then let it cook on high for an extra 30ish minutes, to help it thicken a little. It was delicious! Thank you for the great recipe.
Christina, thanks for taking the time to leave this review! I’m so glad to hear it was a hit.
Love the recipe, do not appreciate the pop up videos that you can’t close!!!!! I tried to close it several times and each time it just opens full screen. My battery just went from 65% to 19% in less than 5 minutes.
Hi Mieke, I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe! I’m sorry for any inconvenience the ads caused you! I will certainly keep paying close attention to the number of ads and how they load. I do truly appreciate your feedback!
Hi Erin!
Thanks so much for this recipe, it looks delicious! I had a quick question – I had read this recipe yesterday after work and grabbed all the ingredients, but hadn’t read that I needed a blender for it! (totally my bad, I’m still a cooking rookie)
So the crockpot is going right now on step 1 and I’m planning to head home for lunch to put the evaporated milk in – but I don’t have a blender to blend everything together unfortunately :/
Do you have any recommendation to help with this? Should I maybe try crushing everything together or something? Or just forget the blending part and end up with a thinner soup? Thanks so much for any help you can provide!! :)
Hi Timmy, blending is important for thickening the soup. Without blending, the soup will be more brothy versus creamy and will be a different texture. The taste will probably still be similar since all the same ingredients are used, but as noted in the blog post, I definitely prefer the blended version. You could try to blend some of the ingredients by hand, as you mentioned. I hope that helps!
Thanks for the quick reply Erin! That helps for sure. I will give it a try and hopefully it turns out OK!
Thanks, Timmy! I’d love to hear how it turns out!
Made this last weekend and my husband, 15 year old daughter and I loved it (the six year old, not so much, mainly because she “saw” what went in it… onions and broccoli!). My 15 year old daughter decided to be a vegetarian a few months back, so I am really trying to find some recipes that work for her AND us – and this was a winner. It was simple, I didn’t change anything, and great results. Of course, I used the vegetable broth for vegetarian version, but it did not affect taste. This will be in regular rotation. Thanks!
Amy, I am so so pleased to hear this, THANK YOU! And thank you for taking time to leave this review and rating. It means so much to me and is really helpful for others considering the recipes too!
Can I cook on low for more hours? Thank you
Hi Buffy, you should cook this soup in LOW for 4-6 hours. I hope you love the recipe if you try it!
Hello, DO you think this recipe could be double in a 6 q pot?
Hi Trish! I have never tried doubling this recipe before, so I’m not sure if it would fit. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to hear how it goes!
It tasted good but the texture was gritty and it was a very thin soup.
Hi Karen, I’m sorry the soup turned out gritty and thin for you. It might be how the vegetables were pureed or that the soup didn’t cook long enough. You could try stirring in extra cheese or Greek yogurt to make it creamier, in case that helps. Regardless, I’m sorry that this didn’t meet your expectations. I know that it is disappointing to not have a recipe turn out!
I made this tonight and although it tasted good it appeared to have curdled, I followed the instructions, so I’m not sure what happened, bummer.
Hi Pankey529, I’m so sorry to hear that you had trouble with this recipe. Did you use fat free milk or cream cheese by chance? Fat free products can curdle more easily, so that could be the cause. I’m happy to hear that the flavors were still tasty!
Can regular milk or 1/2&1/2 be ok instead of evaporated milk? Thank you
Hi Debbie, you can use half and half. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
We absolutely love this soup! My daughter just had braces put on so its difficult for her to eat and since I know how much she loves this I surprised her with it today! I pureed it completely and its perfect for her. I love the nutmeg it really gives it that something something! Thanks Erin!! Cant wait for the cookbook! :)
I’m so happy that it was a hit, Trish! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
So…. Im using a sub for evaporated milk. Im simmered my milk down to make my own evaporated milk. So far this appears to BE AMAZING! Now to see what the kiddos think!
Thank you for the great recipe!
I hope you loved the recipe, Rebecca!
WE LOVED IT! I did not have evaporated milk but simmered my own whole milk down! This recipe is the BOMB! Thank you for sharing Erin!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Rebecca! Thank you for taking the time to share your results!